What is ‘gay and trans panic’? Michigan is latest to ban criminal defense. (2024)

Michigan is the latest state to ban the “gay and trans panic” criminal defense, making it unlawful to use “the discovery of a person’s actual or perceived gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation as justification for the commission of a crime.”

States have increasingly outlawed the defense in recent years, starting with California in 2006. But it is still lawful in most states. Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer (D) signed the bill Tuesday.

Advocates for outlawing the defense point to high-profile cases such as the 2015 murder of David Spencer in Texas, who was stabbed by a friend who said he tried to kiss him. James Miller was sentenced in 2018 to six months in prison after his murder charge was downgraded to criminally negligent homicide following a “gay panic” defense argument from his attorney.

Advertisement

The American Bar Association has called for legislative action to “curtail the availability and effectiveness” of the defense, saying that “successful gay and trans panic defenses constitute a miscarriage of justice.”

What is the gay or trans panic defense?

The legal defense is used when a defendant charged with a violent crime attempts to use the victim’s sexual identity as a mitigating factor in his culpability, with the goal of acquittal or reduced charges.

A man accused of killing another man or trans woman, for example, might argue in court that the victim had either indicated interest in him, tried to sexually assault him or engaged in sexual behavior with him without disclosing their sexual identity.

W. Carsten Andresen, an assistant professor of criminal justice at St. Edward’s University in Austin, has compiled a database of gay and trans panic defense cases from media articles, legal transcripts and academic writing. He found more than 700 instances of the defense being used in murder cases between 1970 and 2024 in the United States, including 18 in Michigan, he said in a phone interview. It was an effective tactic in reducing charges about a third of the time, his analysis of early data found.

Advertisement

Andresen said there were four main ways the argument is used.

The first is provocation, in which a defense attorney argues that a victim “hitting on” a defendant is “so upsetting, and it would be so upsetting to any man, that the violence is understandable,” Andresen said. He added this was used more often as a tactic to reduce charges, for example from first- or second-degree murder to manslaughter.

The second is to bolster a self-defense argument in which the perpetrator of violence alleges the victim sexually assaulted him or attempted to assault him.

The third is insanity, in which the defendant argues that he had such a strong reaction to the actions of an LGBTQ+ person that he broke with reality and used violence, which has typically not been successful in courtrooms, Andresen said.

The fourth is diminished capacity, a lesser version of insanity that argues the victim’s sexual identity affected the perpetrator’s mental state.

What does the Michigan ruling mean?

The Michigan law bans using a person’s real or perceived sexual identity in a provocation defense, a “heat of passion” defense or a reduced mental capacity defense.

Advertisement

Andresen said it empowers judges and prosecutors to stop or object to defense attorneys using a victim’s sexual identity when making arguments to a jury. “There are still ways that the defense attorney will try to get around it,” he said. “But it allows you to be vocal in calling this out and identifying it for what it is.”

“It’s been likened to rape shield laws with women, where if a woman is sexually assaulted, you’re not allowed to bring up her sexual history,” he added. “You hopefully are providing a little bit more context for what a defense attorney is trying to do when they try to insinuate that somebody … is somehow to blame or that the offender is less culpable for the harm that they caused.”

Where else is the panic defense banned?

Twenty states and the District of Columbia have some form of legislation prohibiting an LGBTQ+ panic defense: California, Illinois, Rhode Island, Connecticut, Hawaii, Maine, Nevada, New York, D.C., Colorado, New Jersey, Washington, Maryland, Oregon, Vermont, Virginia, New Mexico, New Hampshire, Delaware, Minnesota and Michigan, according to the National LGBTQ+ Bar Association.

There is legislation pending in Pennsylvania, and it has been introduced but failed in Arizona, Arkansas, Florida, Iowa, Montana, Wisconsin, Georgia, Massachusetts, Nebraska, North Carolina and Texas, the group said.

A federal bill was introduced by Sen. Edward J. Markey (D-Mass.) and Rep. Chris Pappas (D-N.H.) in 2021 and reintroduced in 2023 but has not passed.

What is ‘gay and trans panic’? Michigan is latest to ban criminal defense. (2024)

FAQs

What is ‘gay and trans panic’? Michigan is latest to ban criminal defense.? ›

Michigan is the latest state to ban the “gay and trans panic” criminal defense, making it unlawful to use “the discovery of a person's actual or perceived gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation as justification for the commission of a crime.”

What is the Equality Act in Michigan? ›

In October 2023, insurance companies and corporations within Michigan are explicitly banned from discriminating against individuals on the basis of sexual orientation and gender identity - under a bill that passed both houses of the Michigan Legislature. The Governor of Michigan signed the bill into law.

What is the meaning of gay panic? ›

a historical and outdated term describing a sudden, acute anxiety attack precipitated by (a) the unconscious fear that one might be LGBTQ+ or will act out LGBTQ+ impulses, (b) the fear of being sexually attacked by a person of the same sex, or (c) loss of or separation from a same-sex partner.

What does the Equality Act prohibit? ›

The Equality Act became law in 2010. It covers everyone in Britain and protects people from discrimination, harassment and victimisation. The information on these pages is here to help you understand the law and decide if you have been treated unlawfully.

What is the Pomosexual flag? ›

The pomosexual flag was created in July 2016 by Tumblr user pride-color-schemes. Shades of pretty pink and white are what define the pomosexual pride flag.

What panic state means? ›

Sudden extreme anxiety or fear that may cause irrational thoughts or actions. Panic may include rapid heart rate, flushing (a hot, red face), sweating, and trouble breathing.

What is the meaning of jolly gay? ›

gay, jolly, joyful, merry describe a happy or light-hearted mood. gay suggests a lightness of heart or liveliness of mood that is openly manifested: when hearts were young and gay. jolly indicates a good-humored, natural, expansive gaiety of mood or disposition: a jolly crowd at a party.

What are the main points of the Equality Act? ›

The Equality Act 2010

It prohibits conduct and creates duties in relation to 'protected characteristics'. There are nine protected characteristics, listed in section 4 of the Act, ranging from age through to sexual orientation. The Act prohibits direct and indirect discrimination, and harassment and victimisation.

How do I know if I am covered by the Equality Act? ›

You are covered by the Equality Act if you have a progressive condition like HIV, cancer or multiple sclerosis, even if you are currently able to carry out normal day to day activities. You are protected as soon as you are diagnosed with a progressive condition.

What is the Equal Pay Act in Michigan? ›

The Equal Pay Act requires fair treatment in job compensation for all Michigan workers regardless of their sex. It prohibits pay discrimination based on sex for equal work on jobs that require equal skill, effort and responsibility, and are performed under similar working conditions.

What is the Equal Accommodations Act in Michigan? ›

All persons within the jurisdiction of this state shall be entitled to full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities and privileges of inns, hotels, motels, government housing, restaurants, eating houses, barber shops, billiard parlors, stores, public conveyances on land and water, theatres, motion picture ...

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Jeremiah Abshire

Last Updated:

Views: 5973

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (54 voted)

Reviews: 85% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Jeremiah Abshire

Birthday: 1993-09-14

Address: Apt. 425 92748 Jannie Centers, Port Nikitaville, VT 82110

Phone: +8096210939894

Job: Lead Healthcare Manager

Hobby: Watching movies, Watching movies, Knapping, LARPing, Coffee roasting, Lacemaking, Gaming

Introduction: My name is Jeremiah Abshire, I am a outstanding, kind, clever, hilarious, curious, hilarious, outstanding person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.